| Pos | Player | School | Class | Coach Votes |
| Pitch | Larry Bigham | Midland Trail | Sr. | 10 |
| Pitch | Dale Boone | Greenbrier West | Sr. | 9 |
| Inf | Braydon McClung | Greenbrier West | Jr. | 11 |
| Inf | Brandon Isaac | Summers County | Jr. | 9 |
| Inf | Cody Harrell | Midland Trail | Sr. | 7 |
| Inf | Colton Jones | Summers County | Fr. | 4 |
| Inf | Luke Fraley | James Monroe | Jr. | 3 |
| C | Ethan Holliday | Greenbrier West | Jr. | 5 |
| C | Cooper Ridgeway | James Monroe | Jr. | 4 |
| Out | Aaron Dempsey | Midland Trail | Sr. | 5 |
| Out | David Lester | Greenbrier West | Jr. | 4 |
| Out | Trae Trivolette | Richwood | Jr. | 4 |
| Util | Bo Persinger | Midland Trail | Sr. | 10 |
| Util | Ben Lane | Summers County | Jr. | 9 |
Honorable mention: Gideon Bragg, Midland Trail; Hunter Boggess, James Monroe; Jake Boone, Summers County; Alex Dempsey, Midland Trail; Juston Feamster, James Monroe; Bryce Hart, Richwood; Xander Hudgins, Summers County; Junior Jones, James Monroe; Ryan Oliveros, Summers County; Hayden Ridgeway, Greenbrier West; Dalton Spencer, Richwood; Matt Stutts, James Monroe; Cole Vandall, Greenbrier West.
