| Pos | Player | School | Class | Coaches |
| Votes | ||||
| Pitch | Brilee Redden | Greenbrier West | Fr. | 8 |
| Pitch | Bryleigh Thomas | James Monroe | Soph. | 5 |
| Inf | Preslee Treadway | Greenbrier West | Soph. | 6 |
| Inf | Emma Ames | Greenbrier West | Sr. | 4 |
| Inf | Chloe Burt | James Monroe | Soph. | 4 |
| Inf | Madison Booth | James Monroe | Soph. | 4 |
| C | Syd Sheets | Midland Trail | Sr. | 6 |
| OF | Madison Campbell | Midland Trail | Sr. | 5 |
| OF | Madde Fields | Greenbrier West | Soph. | 5 |
| OF | Joedan Lowe | James Monroe | Jr. | 4 |
| Util | Julie Herndon | Greenbrier West | Jr. | 3 |
| Util | Jenna Stonestreet | Midland Trail | Jr. | 3 |
| Util | Kendyl Giles | Richwood | Sr. | 2 |
| Util | Desirae Plumley | Summers County | Fr. | 2 |
Honorable mention: Michaela Alley, Greenbrier West; Shailyn Wickline, James Monroe; Jayden Bradley, James Monroe; Layla Tompkins, Midland Trail; Neveah Hall, Midland Trail; Ryley Shockey, Midland Trail; Kailey Ballard, Summers County, Anastasia Winters, Summers County; Delaney White, Richwood, Katie Stanley, Richwood.
