| Pos | Player | School | Class | Coach Votes |
| Pitch | Brody Combs | Princeton | Fr. | 6 |
| Pitch | Gabe Patton | Greenbrier East | Jr. | 6 |
| Inf | Darris Boswell | Greenbrier East | Sr. | 7 |
| Inf | Ashton Cochran | Greenbrier East | So. | 6 |
| Inf | Owen Grose | Oak Hill | Fr. | 3 |
| Inf | Zach Jenkins | Princeton | So. | 2 |
| Inf | Chase Tolliver | Woodrow Wilson | Jr. | 2 |
| C | Clayton Morgan | Greenbrier East | Sr. | 5 |
| Out | Ari Payne | Woodrow Wilson | Sr. | 3 |
| Out | Ian Cline | Greenbrier East | Jr. | 2 |
| Out | Lucas Monaghan | Princeton | Jr. | 2 |
| Util | Jayden McLain | Oak Hill | Jr. | 8 |
| Util | Connor Mollohan | Woodrow Wilson | Sr. | 6 |
| Util | Gabe Truman | Oak Hill | Sr. | 4 |
| Util | Grant Cochran | Princeton | Sr. | 3 |
Honorable mention: Gavin Bennett, Greenbrier East; Noah Dunford, Princeton; Ty Evans, Woodrow Wilson; Jackson Gambrell, Woodrow Wilson; Brock Halsey, Princeton; Cole Legg, Oak Hill; Blake Stratton, Woodrow Wilson.
Oak Hill’s Jayden McLain
