| Pos | Player | School | Class | Coaches |
| Votes | ||||
| Pitch | Aubrey Smallwood | Woodrow Wilson | Soph. | 10 |
| Pitch | Josi Ervin | Greenbrier East | Sr. | 7 |
| Inf | Lindsey Black | Greenbrier East | Sr. | 7 |
| Inf | Taylor Boswell | Greenbrier East | Sr. | 5 |
| Inf | Jazz Daubert | Woodrow Wilson | Fr. | 5 |
| Inf | Bailey Willoughby | Oak Hill | Sr. | 4 |
| C | Oivia Plybon | Greenbrier East | Sr. | 5 |
| C | Hailee Jones | Oak Hill | Jr. | 3 |
| Out | Riley Riggs | Princeton | Jr. | 5 |
| Out | Hailey Irvin | Greenbrier East | So. | 3 |
| Util | Emma Johnson | Princeton | Jr. | 4 |
| Util | Lily Carola | Greenbrier East | Jr. | 3 |
| Util | Natalia Meade | Woodrow Wilson | Jr. | 3 |
| Util | Abigail Jenkins | Princeton | Jr. | 3 |
Honorable mention: Presley Bailey, Woodrow Wilson; Sadie Branch, Oak Hill; Gracie Gumm, Greenbrier East; Hayden Jones, Princeton; Addy Salvatore, Oak Hill; Alex Smith, Woodrow Wilson; Alexis Stanley, Oak Hill.
