| Pos. | Player | School | Class | Coaches |
| Votes | ||||
| Pitch | Delaney Buckland | Independence | Sr. | 8 |
| Pitch | Izzy Smith | Bluefield | Jr. | 5 |
| Inf | Avary Bragg | Shady Spring | Fr. | 7 |
| Inf | Alli Hypes | Independence | Jr. | 7 |
| Inf | Keandra Spurlock | Liberty | Jr. | 7 |
| Inf | Abby Richardson | Bluefield | Jr. | 5 |
| Inf | Mallie Lawson | Shady Spring | Sr. | 5 |
| C | Kayley Bane | Wyoming East | Sr. | 4 |
| C | Kaylee Waddell | Shady Spring | Jr. | 4 |
| Out | Zoe Nash | Nicholas County | Soph. | 7 |
| Out | Kendall Martin | Independence | Sr. | 6 |
| Out | Savannah Brehm | Wyoming East | Sr. | 5 |
| Out | Cara Brown | Bluefield | Jr. | 4 |
| Util | Madison Lawson | Bluefield | Soph. | 6 |
| Util | Emma Lilly | Independence | Soph. | 4 |
| Util | Cambrea Neal | Nicholas County | Jr. | 4 |
| Util | Myles Meadows | Westside | Fr. | 2 |
Honorable Mention: Brooklyn Blankenship, Shady Spring; Kassidy Bradbury, Independence; Paytin Brehm, Wyoming East; Kenidi Creager, Shady Spring; Alyson Griffith, Liberty; Sophie Hall, Bluefield; Jayda Hamrick, Westside; McKenzie Hanshaw, Nicholas County; Josie Hartshorn, Liberty; Abby Hilleary, Nicholas County; Andrea Laxton, Wyoming East; Harmony Mills, Independence; Kinley Morgan, Westside; Katie Mullens, Liberty; Caril Raye, Wyoming East; Grace Richardson, Bluefield; Ashley Stephenson, Nicholas County; Emma Simpson, Wyoming East; Bella Sturgill, Shady Spring; Keslie Walker, Nicholas County.
